Krylon vs Rustoleum: Which is the Best?

Krylon vs Rustoleum

The power struggle between Keylon and Rustoleum is one we might never see the end of, at least not among users who appear to have conflicting ideas concerning which is the superior brand. This article takes an in-debt analysis into both brands to provide context on the Krylon vs. Rustoleum topic and everything that there is to know about the duo. Emphasis will also be placed on the merits and demerits of these spray paints and how to get the best results from their use. This promises to be a highly informative article, strap yourself in, and enjoy the ride!

Let’s dive right into the business of the day

What is Krylon?

Krylon or Rustoleum? Regardless of the side, you’re on concerning the debate of Krylon vs. Rustoleum; you can’t deny that the other is a good product in its own stead. We’ll start this detailed analysis by taking a look at Krylon.

The history of this world heavyweight, Krylon, dates back to as early as 1947. Howard Kester of Philadelphia founded what was then the world’s first aerosol paints; today Krylon Inc is the largest supplier of aerosol paints in the whole world. From the moment it was established, it was clear that the future of the paint industry was never going to be the same after that revolutionary product came into the market.

Foster & Kester introduced the first Krylon products in 1947. It’s known that the inspiration to develop Krylon was derived from DuPont Corporation. They (DuPont) had successfully rolled out a formula that enabled the combination of gas and liquid into a single spray can.

Kester -a developer of brush-on protective acrylic coatings commonly used in the commercial art industry-  found a way to make his coatings into a product that was superior in terms of advantages to the typical brush-on method. (Amazon Link )

How did Krylon derive its name?

DuPont’s introduction of nylon quite shortly after Krester had brought his idea into the market left Krester very amazed. In short, Krylon got its name due to Krester’s great admiration for DuPont’s work. Kester took the first and the last letter of his name and added it to “kylon,” dropping the first letter “n” from nylon. Krylon.

In the early 1950s, sales of Krylon aerosol clear coatings skyrocketed due to modifications in its market strategies. Before this, Krester’s coatings were very much limited to arts and advertising businesses. The addition of colors to the coatings hiked the sales of the product.

Krylon is known to be outstanding in its package designs, colors, and innovative policies. Krylon’s collection is stocked with products suitable for both interior and exterior use. Multipurpose products, rust preventive products, plastics, brush-on products, specialty products, and craft products are the various types of products contained in its collection. Krylon maintains its relevance in the market through its innovative product ideas, outstanding product designs, and colors.

One feature unique to Krylon is its ability to dry quickly, in just mere minutes. This is undoubtedly a stand out feature. Most people who prefer Krylon mention this as the feature that gives Krylon an edge over Rustoleum in this debate. Krylon or Rustoleum? You’ll make up your mind as we proceed with this article.

Enough about history now, let’s delve into hard facts. We will now offer you an unbiased examination of the advantages and disadvantages of Krylon.

Advantages of Krylon

There are some eye-catching advantages associated with this spray paint product. The purpose of this section is to present to you the attributes that make Krylon the big name that it is. We’ll take a look at the disadvantages much later.

# Again, one very outstanding benefit of Krylon is its ability to dry quickly. With this product, you don’t need to wait for long before your new paint dries up. Krylon focuses on this aspect when developing its products, and as a result, they have products that can typically dry up in a matter of minutes.

# Another key attraction is that Krylon offers a collection with a variety of colors to pick from. I must mention that the availability of these options is highly attractive to buyers and users alike. Another advantage is that Krylon products offer surface uniformity.

# The competitive prices of Krylon spray paints add to its huge list of merits. Undoubtedly, a good product with a reasonable price from a company armed with a trustworthy reputation will always be an outstanding option when considering how to spend your money. That’s exactly the case with the Krylon products.

Disadvantages of Krylon

It’d be absurd if this section isn’t looked into. As much as I sing the praises of Krylon spray paints, I’ll also try to be meticulous when listing its failings too.

# One of such very notable demerits is its inability to work suitably with vinyl-coated fabrics. This is large because the Krylon spray paints contain some resin components.

# It requires close attention in picking the environment you intend to do your spraying int. This is very important because the nature of Krylon spray paint makes it susceptible to dust. You don’t need to be told how detrimental dust is to fresh paint, so it’s best to pick a suitable environment free of dust to do your painting to achieve the desired result.

This article may not settle the debate Krylon vs. Rustoleum, but it promises to do unbiased justice in describing what they are, and the pros and cons associated with each of them.

We’ve been dwelling very much on Krylon, so let’s get started with Rustoleum

What is Rustoleum?

Before we proceed to talk about Rustoleum spray paint colors or before attempting to talk about Rustoleum vs. Krylon, we’ll talk about Rustoleum starting from its history and how it came to attain its current status in the paint and art market.

The company was founded in 1921 by a sea captain, Robert Ferguson of Illinois. He was inspired when he found that fish oils that spilled on rusty metal decks hindered corrosion from escalating. He went on to put whale oil into the formula shortly afterward. However, over the years, the whale oil was removed from the formula and replaced with resins gotten from latex, alkyds, epoxies, etc.

In the US and Canada, in terms of market shares, Rustoleum holds the record for the largest value in rust prevention, specialty, decoration, and the professional section of the small-project paint products. The Rustoleum company is owned and run today by RPM International Inc.; before 1994, it was a family-owned company. Back in 2015, the company was able to clinch a hallmark by reaching 1 billion dollars in revenue.

I’ll mention a few of the brands associated with the company, but there are numerous, so we’ll do with them just key brands. They include brands such as:

  • High performance
  • NeverWet
  • Painter’s Touch
  • Universal
  • Varathane
  • Stops Rust
  • Zinsser
  • Watco

Also, in 2012 the company took over Synta Inc., in 2014 it acquired the Krud Kutter Inc., and the  Citadel Restoration and Repair Inc., and then the Seal Krete in 2016. It’s a world brand today with the international partnership with:

  • Rust-Tech, South Africa.
  • Truworth Homes, India.
  • Elam Professional Adhesives Ltd, Israel.

When looking at the Krylon vs. Rustoleum in terms of graffiti, one quickly discovers that Rustoleum is quite thicker and much more durable. It’s the most durable among all spray paints, and this is evident in the loyalty accorded it by American graffiti artists. Krylon, on the other hand, isn’t so popular in artistic circles. Krylon was once a favorite, but it has fallen behind in the pecking order. Krylon vs. Rustoleum? When speaking about Krylon vs. Rustoleum in graffiti, Krylon is floored by the legendary Rustoleum.

When comparing these two brands, you can easily deduce that the advantages they have over each other is mostly dependent on the surface or medium of application. Krylon edges over Rustoleum by a large margin when used in painting guns. Krylon can come out on top when used on guns due to its ability to dry quickly. It takes too long for Rustoleum to completely dry out. So, Krylon vs. Rustoleum for graffiti: Rustoleum; Krylon vs. Rustoleum for guns: Krylon. ( Amazon Link )

Advantages of Rustoleum

There are lots of advantages associated with Rustoleum. Honestly, It wouldn’t be a worldwide brand if it wasn’t so impressive. Some of the most outstanding pros of Rustoleum will be discussed in this section.

# One of the most notable advantages of Rustoleum spray paints is that they are pretty easy to apply, and little or no additional materials or technology is required to get your intended result.

# It is much more durable than any other spray paint. For example, Rustoleum NeverWet possessing hydrophobic properties, which ensure that the painted material repels water and moisture. This is a huge advantage because water-resistant paints tend to last longer. Also, it eliminates the need for repainting. This waterproofing quality ensures that the surface cannot be easily damaged by heat.
Furthermore, it’s water resistance capacities is unmatched in the paint industry. This outstanding capacity makes Rustoleum perfect wheel paint. Rustoleum is also a very good caliper paint due to its rust removing capacities, durability, and ability to resist high temperatures

# Krylon vs. Rustoleum, in terms of pricing both spray paints, are affordable and well within the budget of most individuals or professionals who intend to do painting jobs.

We’ll jump straight into the disadvantages of Rustoleum.

Disadvantages of Rustoleum

# The time needed to dry up completely? Rustoleum is defeated in this aspect. It takes so long to completely dry up when compared to Krylon that completely dries up in a couple of minutes. This is unprecedented, considering the standards set by other rivals in the industry. Spray paints dry quicker, but that’s never the case with Rustoleum.

krylon vs rustoleum spray paint

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Question: Is Krylon spray paint any good?

Ans: Yes, undoubtedly, Krylon spray paint is a really good product when a lot of factors are being considered. There’s availability of lots of colors to pick from, it’s the ability to dry very quickly, etc. Certainly, it has its downside when placed side by side with other products just the same way every product has. It can offer a really neat paint job if applied on a suitable surface. Krylon vs. Rustoleum guns: Krylon is so much more suitable in this instance but fails woefully when brought into the debate of Krylon vs. Rustoleum graffiti.

Question: Can you paint Krylon over Rustoleum?

Ans: Obviously, you can do whatever you choose to do. You can choose to paint whatever you want over just anything, but you really shouldn’t do it with Krylon over Rustoleum. Regardless of color, clear or anything, it’s a bad idea because it’s going to wrinkle. Also, I’m very certain that your primary intention is to get a great paint job and not an ugly one. It’s not perfect together, just don’t do it. Since Krylon changed its formula, it barely mixes with any other paint without wrinkling. There are cases of wrinkling with Krylon-Krylon combo. This link will help you understand how to paint brake calipers and the best products to help you get the best results.

Question: What is the most durable spray paint?

Ans: There are lots of really amazing spray paints out there in terms of durability and quality. Generally, measuring the durability of spray paint would make it difficult to answer the question. This is largely because most spray paints have different durability capacities on various surfaces. However, answering within the context of this article, Rustoleum is very durable, and it surpasses Krylon in terms of durability by miles. Its ability to stick without compromising even in really hot temperatures sets it apart from other spray paints.

Question: What type of paint is Krylon colorMaster?

Ans: Acrylic lacquer. Keep in mind that acrylics are fast-drying paints and are water-soluble but become water-resistant when dry. With our knowledge of what Krylon paints are and their characteristics, it’s quite easy to deduce that it suits perfectly in this category, acrylics. The Krylon ColorMaster typically dries up in about 10 minutes as opposed to the hours needed for an enamel paint to totally dry up. I think it’d be best to mention here that when looking at Krylon vs. Rustoleum, Krylon tends more to acrylics while Rustoleum tends more to enamels due to its oil base.

Question: Does Rustoleum need a primer?

Ans: Yes, it’s good practice to use primers. The primary role of a primer is to enable the paint to stick better and more uniformly, help seal holes on surfaces, prevent rust on iron and steel. With all the good things that I have to say about primers, I think even Rustoleum need primers. However, you should check the spray can go on purchase as ALL Rustoleum spray paints don’t need primers. A good example of when it’s not advisable to use a primer is on painted wood. For an unstained bare wood, Painter’s Touch Ultra Cover 2x primer is best.

Krylon vs. Rustoleum Mirror Spray Paint Comparison YouTube

Final Words

Spray paints have been existent in our world for quite a long time, and there are some top names in the market whenever you inquire about them. On the Krylon vs. Rustoleum debate, the change of formula has affected Krylon’s stand on the world stage rather negatively than in a positive way. It’s still a decent product, excellent for some. However, Rustoleum is still high up there with the very best. Its durability sets it apart from most paints. This is phenomenal on its part. Its obvious con is its inability to dry up quickly like most spray paints. It’s then apparent that while they are really good spray paints, they have their failings too.

Read More: Best Parts Washer Solvent and Cleaner Reviews

Recent Posts